Message |
Details |
Quoting rdodolak:
Quote: Do you want a Steelbook or regular profile?
What I own is the steelbook so that would be great--thank you! | Posted: Topic Replies: 5, Topic Views: 3746 |
|
Hi There,
I was hoping for some help here. My UHD drive for some reason won't read the UHD disc with the Theatrical Cut in the new US release. I would really like to have a child profile added for this release since it's a separate disc, but since my drive won't read it I'm unable to contribute it myself.
If anyone that this release (either steelbook or regular) and an UHD drive that will read the disc and can contribute, I'd really appreciate it.
Hoping someone can help me out--thanks in advance! | Posted: Topic Replies: 5, Topic Views: 3746 |
|
Quoting MickySpoon:
Quote: I hope it's okay if I give a short update on behalf of primetime21.
Of course; thanks for the help!
Man this looked like a runaway win for Ron but Ronald really caught up.
However, it looks like as of now, with only one title pending and it 33-30, Ron Eng is the common name! | Posted: Topic Replies: 25, Topic Views: 12641 |
|
Quoting MickySpoon:
Quote: You must mark the entry of The Wild Thornberry's Movie ---> Ron Eng as invalid. He is credited as Sound FX Editor. And you must mark the entry of The Nun ---> Ronald Eng as invalid. He is credited as Ron Eng.
sorry I missed the invalid-both updated! | Posted: Topic Replies: 25, Topic Views: 12641 |
|
Quoting huskersports:
Quote: You still have The Hunted under both names (Ron Eng is the credit).
Thank you! I will fix--it's annoying that I can't continuously edit the first post | Posted: Topic Replies: 25, Topic Views: 12641 |
|
Quoting Nosferatu:
Quote: Quoting ObiKen:
Quote:
There is no dilemma if you follow the combo set rules. • The parent profile accurately conveys the information for the main feature on the primary media only. • The child profile accurately conveys the information for the main feature on the secondary media only. • If you don't like child profiles, add the child features to your local database and lock it (just don't contribute it).
This makes complete sense, thank you
It seems it's our yearly debate about this, where some people insist it states in the rules you put all the features on the parent disc, despite all of the evidence to the contrary as is expressed here.
Unfortunately it doesn't seem like reason is followed as was stated so succinctly by ObiKen, and people vote their personal preference (whichever that may be) over the rules, or point to anecdotal evidence of a profile being approved, which makes no sense to me because profiles have been approved and denied each way. If every profile approval was able to be claims as the basis for a rule, we would have no rules because everything would be contradicted. Thus we should rely on the actual rules as written, which is clear, and not leaps of faith or suspect inferences. | Posted: Topic Replies: 41, Topic Views: 12226 |
|
I think you have your consensus, but either way I think the rules would support its removal no matter what. I don't see where it says Additional Script Material would be valid. | Posted: Topic Replies: 4, Topic Views: 3542 |
|
Getting very close but not enough to make a clear determination Updated 10/25
CLT: Ron Eng 64/656 Ronald Eng 95/790 Ronald H. Eng 1/18
Ron Eng - 32 confirmed The Adventures of Elmo in Grouchland confirmed by greyghost American Wedding confirmed by Primetime21 Balto confirmed by greyghost Brother Bear 2 confirmed by mreeder50 Bug confirmed by bigdaddyhorse Case 39 confirmed by greyghost Coraline confirmed by Kluge First Snow confirmed by bigdaddyhorse For The Cause The Grace Card confirmed by MickySpoon The Heyday of the Insensitive Bastards confirmed by MickySpoon How To Be Single confirmed by MickySpoon The Hunted confirmed by huskersports I Know Who Killed Me confirmed by bigdaddyhorse JFK: Destiny Betrayed confirmed by Primetime21 JFK Revisited: Through The Looking Glass confirmed by Primetime21 Kicking & Screaming confirmed by T!M The Ladies Man confirmed by T!M Lilo & Stitch 2 confirmed by mreeder50 The Lion King 1 1/2 confirmed by Primetime21 The Lost confirmed by bigdaddyhorse Lost in Space confirmed by Kluge The Mirror Has Two Faces confirmed by T!M Mulholland Dr. confirmed by Primetime21 My Son, My Son, What Have You Done confirmed by Kluge The Nun confirmed by MickySpoon Rules of Engagement confirmed by huskersports Some Velvet Morning confirmed by MickySpoon The Straight Story confirmed by Primetime21 Tinker Bell confirmed by MickySpoon The Trigger Effect confirmed by MickySpoon Twins Peaks: The Return confirmed by Primetime21 The Wild Thornberry's Movie invalid - confirmed by MickySpoon The Woods confirmed by bigdaddyhorse
Ronald Eng - 21 confirmed The Adventures of Elmo in Grouchland invalid - confirmed by greyghost American Wedding invalid - confirmed by Primetime21 Amistad confirmed by greyghost As Cool As I Am confirmed by MickySpoon Beauty and the Beast: The Enchanted Christmas invalid - confirmed by greyghost Bleak Moments (cast role--same person?) Branded confirmed by greyghost Case 39 invalid - confirmed by greyghost Chucky: Season One Chucky: Season Two The Clearing Death at a Funeral confirmed by T!M Earth to Echo confirmed by MickySpoon The Emperor's New Groove 2: Kronk's New Groove confirmed by mreeder50 Empire of the Sun (cast role--same person?) Eye in the Sky confirmed by T!M Final Encounter For The Cause Free Willy 2 confirmed by mreeder50 Happily confirmed by T!M Hostel 3 The Hunchback of Notre Dame II The Hunted invalid - confirmed by huskersports Independence Day confirmed by Kluge Indivisible confirmed by MickySpoon Inland Empire confirmed by Primetime21 The Jungle Book 2 confirmed by MickySpoon Kristin's Christmas Past confirmed by MickySpoon Lakeview Terrace confirmed by MickySpoon Lilo & Stitch 2 invalid - confirmed by mreeder50 The Lion King 1 1/2 invalid - confirmed by Primetime21 Lost in Space invalid - confirmed by Kluge Microbes and Men (cast role--same person?) My Son, My Son, What Have You Done invalid - confirmed by Kluge The Nun invalid - confirmed by MickySpoon Open Season 3 confirmed by mreeder50 Operation Takedown ParaNorman confirmed by mreeder50 The Perfect Score confirmed by T!M Raised By Wolves: Season One Recess: School's Out Return to Never Land confirmed by MickySpoon Rules of Engagement invalid - confirmed by huskersports Silent Fall Star Trek: Insurrection invalid - confirmed by huskersports The Straight Story invalid - confirmed by Primetime21 Takedown Tarzan 2 confirmed by MickySpoon Tenko: Series 1: Part 1 (cast role--same person?) Tenko: Series 3: Part 1 (cast role--same person?) Tinker Bell invalid - invalid - confirmed by MickySpoon Tomb Raider The Three Musketeers The Wickerman confirmed by bigdaddyhorse Wild Mustang 3D The Woods invalid - confirmed by bigdaddyhorse
Ronald H. Eng - 1 confirmed Beauty and the Beast: The Enchanted Christmas confirmed by greyghost | Posted: Topic Replies: 25, Topic Views: 12641 |
|
Getting closer but not enough to make a clear determination Updated 10/19
CLT: Ron Eng 64/656 Ronald Eng 95/790 Ronald H. Eng 1/18
Ron Eng - 25 confirmed The Adventures of Elmo in Grouchland confirmed by greyghost American Wedding confirmed by Primetime21 Balto confirmed by greyghost Brother Bear 2 confirmed by mreeder50 Bug confirmed by bigdaddyhorse Case 39 confirmed by greyghost Coraline confirmed by Kluge First Snow confirmed by bigdaddyhorse For The Cause The Grace Card The Heyday of the Insensitive Bastards How To Be Single The Hunted confirmed by huskersports I Know Who Killed Me confirmed by bigdaddyhorse JFK: Destiny Betrayed confirmed by Primetime21 JFK Revisited: Through The Looking Glass confirmed by Primetime21 Kicking & Screaming confirmed by T!M The Ladies Man confirmed by T!M Lilo & Stitch 2 confirmed by mreeder50 The Lion King 1 1/2 confirmed by Primetime21 The Lost confirmed by bigdaddyhorse Lost in Space confirmed by Kluge The Mirror Has Two Faces confirmed by T!M Mulholland Dr. confirmed by Primetime21 My Son, My Son, What Have You Done confirmed by Kluge The Nun Rules of Engagement confirmed by huskersports Some Velvet Morning The Straight Story confirmed by Primetime21 Tinker Bell The Trigger Effect Twins Peaks: The Return confirmed by Primetime21 The Wild Thornberry's Movie The Woods confirmed by bigdaddyhorse
Ronald Eng - 13 confirmed The Adventures of Elmo in Grouchland invalid - confirmed by greyghost American Wedding invalid - confirmed by Primetime21 Amistad confirmed by greyghost As Cool As I Am Beauty and the Beast: The Enchanted Christmas invalid - confirmed by greyghost Bleak Moments (cast role--same person?) Branded confirmed by greyghost Case 39 invalid - confirmed by greyghost Chucky: Season One Chucky: Season Two The Clearing Death at a Funeral confirmed by T!M Earth to Echo The Emperor's New Groove 2: Kronk's New Groove confirmed by mreeder50 Empire of the Sun (cast role--same person?) Eye in the Sky confirmed by T!M Final Encounter For The Cause Free Willy 2 confirmed by mreeder50 Happily confirmed by T!M Hostel 3 The Hunchback of Notre Dame II The Hunted Independence Day confirmed by Kluge Indivisible Inland Empire confirmed by Primetime21 The Jungle Book 2 Kristin's Christmas Past Lakeview Terrace Lilo & Stitch 2 invalid - confirmed by mreeder50 The Lion King 1 1/2 invalid - confirmed by Primetime21 Lost in Space invalid - confirmed by Kluge Microbes and Men (cast role--same person?) My Son, My Son, What Have You Done invalid - confirmed by Kluge The Nun Open Season 3 confirmed by mreeder50 Operation Takedown ParaNorman confirmed by mreeder50 The Perfect Score confirmed by T!M Raised By Wolves: Season One Recess: School's Out Return to Never Land Rules of Engagement Silent Fall Star Trek: Insurrection invalid - confirmed by huskersports The Straight Story invalid - confirmed by Primetime21 Takedown Tarzan 2 Tenko: Series 1: Part 1 (cast role--same person?) Tenko: Series 3: Part 1 (cast role--same person?) Tinker Bell Tomb Raider The Three Musketeers The Wickerman confirmed by bigdaddyhorse Wild Mustang 3D The Woods invalid - confirmed by bigdaddyhorse
Ronald H. Eng - 1 confirmed Beauty and the Beast: The Enchanted Christmas confirmed by greyghost | Posted: Topic Replies: 25, Topic Views: 12641 |
|
I'm trying to find the common name for Sound Engineer Ron/Ronald Eng--lots of duplicates in the CLT. There are also a few entries with cast roles under Ronald, so if that ends up being common a BY may be needed as well:
CLT: Ron Eng 64/656 Ronald Eng 95/790
Ron Eng - 15 confirmed The Adventures of Elmo in Grouchland American Wedding confirmed by Primetime21 Balto Brother Bear 2 confirmed by mreeder50 Bug Case 39 Coraline confirmed by Kluge First Snow For The Cause The Grace Card The Heyday of the Insensitive Bastards How To Be Single The Hunted I Know Who Killed Me JFK: Destiny Betrayed confirmed by Primetime21 JFK Revisited: Through The Looking Glass confirmed by Primetime21 Kicking & Screaming confirmed by T!M The Ladies Man confirmed by T!M Lilo & Stitch 2 confirmed by mreeder50 The Lion King 1 1/2 confirmed by Primetime21 The Lost Lost in Space confirmed by Kluge The Mirror Has Two Faces confirmed by T!M Mulholland Dr. confirmed by Primetime21 My Son, My Son, What Have You Done confirmed by Kluge The Nun Rules of Engagement Some Velvet Morning The Straight Story confirmed by Primetime21 Tinker Bell The Trigger Effect Twins Peaks: The Return confirmed by Primetime21 The Wild Thornberry's Movie The Woods
Ronald Eng - 8 confirmed The Adventures of Elmo in Grouchland American Wedding invalid confirmed by Primetime21 Amistad As Cool As I Am Beauty and the Beast: The Enchanted Christmas Bleak Moments (cast role--same person?) Branded Case 39 Chucky: Season One Chucky: Season Two The Clearing Death at a Funeral confirmed by T!M Earth to Echo The Emperor's New Groove 2 Empire of the Sun (cast role--same person?) Eye in the Sky confirmed by T!M Final Encounter For The Cause Free Willy 2 Happily confirmed by T!M Hostel 3 The Hunchback of Notre Dame II: Kronk's New Groove The Hunted Independence Day confirmed by Kluge Indivisible Inland Empire confirmed by Primetime21 The Jungle Book 2 Kristin's Christmas Past Lakeview Terrace Lilo & Stitch 2 invalid - confirmed by mreeder50 The Lion King 1 1/2 invalid - confirmed by Primetime21 Lost in Space invalid - confirmed by Kluge Microbes and Men (cast role--same person?) My Son, My Son, What Have You Done invalid - confirmed by Kluge The Nun Open Season 3 confirmed by mreeder50 Operation Takedown ParaNorman confirmed by mreeder50 The Perfect Score confirmed by T!M Raised By Wolves: Season One Recess: School's Out Return to Never Land Rules of Engagement Silent Fall Star Trek: Insurrection The Straight Story invalid - confirmed by Primetime21 Takedown Tarzan 2 Tenko: Series 1: Part 1 (cast role--same person?) Tenko: Series 3: Part 1 (cast role--same person?) Tinker Bell Tomb Raider The Three Musketeers The Wickerman Wild Mustang 3D The Woods | Posted: Topic Replies: 25, Topic Views: 12641 |
|